Zadnje novice

09.10.2013

Videoposnetek kot dokaz v kazenskem postopku (Tehtaje med pravico do zasebnosti in pravico do osebne varnosti oškodovanca)

 

1. primer (Sodba I Ips 375/2007)


Če je obdolženčevo ravnanje zaznala vidna videokamera pred oškodovančevo hišo, obdolženec ne more uživati varstva zasebnosti, sajvideonadzor zagotavlja pravico do osebne varnosti oškodovanca inza snemanje ni potrebno soglasje oseb, ki se znajdejo v nadzorovanem območju.

Obdolženčev zagovornik zatrjuje, da je videoposnetek pridobljen s kršitvijo obsojenčeve pravice do zasebnosti, zaradi česar bi ga bilo kot nedovoljenega izločiti iz dokaznega gradiva. Pri preizkusu vložnikovih trditev je treba najprej ugotoviti, ali je do posega v pravico do zasebnosti sploh prišlo, in šele nato, ali je poseg protipraven ali ne. V konkretnem primeru imamo opraviti s položajem, v katerem druga ob drugo trčita dve ustavno varovani praviciČlovekove pravice ne uživajo neomejenega varstvaomejene so s človekovimi pravicami drugih in v primerih, ko to določa zakon (tretji odstavek 15. člena Ustave). Na vprašanje, kdaj je zasebnosti treba zagotoviti pravno varstvo, nudi odgovor t.i. koncept pričakovane zasebnosti. Zasebnost, tako v prostorskem kot v funkcionalnem pogledu, bo varovana takrat oziroma dokler bo posameznik tako pričakovanje izrazil na navzven zaznaven način in kolikor bo to pričakovanje objektivno upravičljivo. Tako pričakovanje ni objektivno upravičljivo takrat, kadar stoji posameznikovi pravici do zasebnostinasproti druga ustavno varovana pravica in ki ji je treba dati prednosti

Vrhovno sodišče šteje za pravilno mnenje višjega sodišča, da bi zahteva po soglasju oseb, ki se znajdejo v nadzorovanem območju,nesorazmerno posegla v uresničevanje pravice do osebne varnosti. Njihova zasebnost in pravica do svobodnega odločanja v lastnih stvareh je v zadostni meri varovana s tem, da se posameznik nadzora zaveda in temu prilagodi svoje ravnanje

V takih okoliščinah se mora po presoji Vrhovnega sodišča varstvo obsojenčeve zasebnosti umakniti pravici do osebnega varstva oškodovanca.

 
 

2. primer (Sodba I Ips 43776/2010-50)


Z namestitvijo video kamere tako, da je omogočala nadzor nad parkirnim mestom v garažni hiši, kjer je imela oškodovanka parkirano svoje vozilo, oškodovanka ni posegla v zasebnost obsojenca, ker obsojenec na tem mestu ni mogel uživati varstva zasebnosti.

Oškodovanka je v letu 2001 z namenom varovanja svojega premoženja in izsleditve storilca, v garažni hiši namestila video kamero tako, da je omogočala nadzor nad njenim parkirnim mestom v garažni hiši, to je nad mestom kjer je imela oškodovanka parkirano svoje vozilo. Ob tako ugotovljenih konkretnih okoliščinah Vrhovno sodišče soglaša s presojo sodišč v izpodbijani pravnomočni sodbi, da s takšno namestitvijo kamere oškodovanka ni posegla v zasebnost obsojenca, ker obsojenec na tem mestu, ki ga je pokrivala video kamera, ni mogel uživati varstva zasebnosti. Video kamera, ki je bila nameščena nad prednjim delom oškodovankinega vozila, je bila nameščena tako, da je bila vidna in opazna vsakomur, ki se je v garažni hiši približal parkiranemu oškodovankinemu vozilu, kar nenazadnje izhaja tudi iz zagovora obsojenca, video nadzor pa je obsegal le nadzor nad vozilom parkiranim na oškodovankinem točno določenem parkirnem mestu v garažni hiši, kar ustreza namenu zagotavljanja pravice do varnosti oškodovanke (ki obsega tudi varnost posameznikovega premoženja) in se mora v takem primeruvarstvo obsojenčeve zasebnosti umakniti pravici do osebnega varstva oškodovanke.
 
 

3. primer (Sodba I Ips 5909/2011-170)


Oškodovanka je obsojenca na skrivaj fotografirala na javnem kraju v obrambi svoje pravice do osebne varnosti, ki ji jo zagotavlja 34. člen URS. V primeru kolizije dveh ustavnih pravic (pravice do zasebnosti iz 35. člena URS in pravice do osebne varnosti iz 34. člena URS) je treba z uporabo načela sorazmernosti ugotoviti, katera izmed njih ima prednost. Fotografiranje storilca kaznivega dejanja, tik preden je začel izvrševati kaznivo dejanje, je bilo v konkretnem primeru nedvomno primeren ukrep, ki je preprečil nadaljevanje kaznivih dejanj nad oškodovanko, legitimnega cilja, osebne varnosti oškodovanke, pa se ni dalo doseči z blažjim sredstvom. Fotografiranje storilca kaznivega dejanja ter posredovanje fotografij organom pregona je v konkretnem primeru tudi v skladu s tehtanjem pomena cilja ter težo posega.
 
Vir: http://www.pravnitelefon.si/pravne-novice/videoposnetek-kot-dokaz-v-kazenskem-postopku-tehtaje-med-pra

Kazenski zakonik Republike Slovenije – KZ 
(Uradni list RS, št. 63/94 z dne 13. 10. 1994)



Neupravičeno prisluškovanje in zvočno snemanje

148. člen



(1) Kdor neupravičeno s posebnimi napravami prisluškuje pogovoru ali izjavi, ki mu nista namenjena, ali ju zvočno snema, ali kdor takšen pogovor ali takšno izjavo neposredno prenaša tretji osebi, ali ji takšen posnetek predvaja ali kako drugače omogoči, da se z njim neposredno seznani, se kaznuje z denarno kaznijo ali z zaporom do enega leta.
(2) Enako se kaznuje, kdor zvočno snema njemu namenjeno zaupno izjavo drugega brez njegove privolitve z namenom, da bi takšno izjavo zlorabil, ali kdor takšno izjavo neposredno prenaša tretji osebi ali ji takšen posnetek predvaja ali ji kako drugače omogoči, da se z njim neposredno seznani.
(3) Če stori dejanje iz prvega ali drugega odstavka tega člena uradna oseba z zlorabo uradnega položaja ali uradnih pravic ali poskusi to storiti, se kaznuje z zaporom od treh mesecev do petih let.
(4) Pregon za dejanje iz prvega odstavka tega člena se začne na predlog, za dejanje iz drugega odstavka pa na zasebno tožbo.

 

VIDEONADZOR NA DELOVNEM MESTU

In addition to mandatory cookies, we also use analytical and advertising cookies, as well as social network cookies on the Spy Shop website.

If you agree with this, please click on the I ACCEPT button. For a detailed description and in order to set the use of individual cookies, click on the COOKIE SETTINGS link.

Cookie Settings
×
Managing cookies on the Spy Shop website
Mandatory cookies

are cookies that are essential for the proper functioning of the website, whereby the transmission of information in the communication network would not be possible without them. These cookies are also necessary in order for us to offer you the services, which are available on our website. They allow you to log in to the user profile, select the language, agree to the terms and conditions and identify the session of the user. We are not obliged to obtain consent for their use.

Analytical cookies

These cookies help us understand how our visitors use our website. They help us improve the user experience and identify user requirements and trends. We only use these cookies if you have explicitly consented to their use.

Advertising cookies

Third-party plug-ins and tools used as cookies enable various functionalities to work, help us analyse the frequency of visits and how the website is used. If an individual does not agree to the use of these cookies, they will not be installed, while it may however happen, that some interesting features of the website will not be available. We only use these cookies if you have explicitly consented to their use.

Social network cookies

These cookies make it possible for us to provide content for posts on social media and record your actions so that we may provide a more personal and enhanced user experience. We use these cookies only if you are logged into a Twitter, Facebook or Google user account when using the website.

1. General information about cookies 1.1. What are cookies?

Cookies are small text files that most modern websites store on the devices of their visitors, i.e. people who access certain websites on the Internet with their devices. The storing of cookies is under the complete control of the user, since users can easily configure their browser to restrict or disable the storage of cookies.

While visiting the website and its subpages and performing operations on the website, your computer, phone or tablet, automatically or after gaining your explicit consent, stores certain cookies through which various data can be recorded.

1.2. How do they work and why we use them?

Each visitor or shopper is assigned a cookie in order to identify him and ensure traceability at the beginning of each use of the online store. The servers provided to the company by the subcontractor automatically collect data on how visitors, shop owners or shoppers use the online store and store this data in the form of an activity log.

The servers store information about the use of the online store, statistics and IP numbers. Data on the use of the online store by shoppers can be used by the company for compiling anonymous statistics that help us improve the user experience as well as market products and / or services through an online store.

Indirectly and upon obtaining consent, the online store may also store external service cookies on the visitor's or shopper's device (e.g. Google Analytics) which are used to collect data on website visits. Regarding external services, the rules and general conditions on the processing of personal data, which are available at the links below, apply.

2. Permission to use cookies

If the settings of the browser with which you visit the website are such, that they accept all cookies, it means that you agree to their use. In case you do not want to use cookies on this website or you want to remove them, you may follow the procedure below. Removing or blocking cookies may result in suboptimal performance of this website.

3. Mandatory and optional cookies and your consent 3.1. We are not required to gain your consent for the use of mandatory cookies:

Mandatory cookies are cookies, that are essential for the proper functioning of the website, whereby the transmission of information in the communication network would not be possible without them. These cookies are also necessary in order for us to offer you the services, which are available on our website. They enable login into the user profile, language selection, agreeing to the terms and conditions and user session identification.

3.2. Cookies that are not necessary for the normal operation of the website, and for which we are obliged to obtain your consent (optional cookies):

Analytical cookies

These cookies help us understand how our visitors use our website. They help us improve the user experience and identify user requirements and trends. We only use these cookies if you have explicitly consented to their use.

Advertising cookies

Third-party plug-ins and tools used as cookies enable various functionalities to work, help us analyse the frequency of visits and how the website is used. If an individual does not agree to the use of these cookies, they will not be installed, while it may however happen, that some interesting features of the website will not be available. We only use these cookies if you have explicitly consented to their use.

Social network cookies

These cookies make it possible for us to provide content for posts on social media and record your actions so that we may provide a more personal and enhanced user experience. We use these cookies only if you are logged into a Twitter, Facebook or Google user account when using the website.

4. How to manage cookies?

You can manage cookies by clicking on the "Cookie settings" link in the footer of the website.

You can also control and change cookie settings in your own web browser.

In case you want to delete cookies from your device, we advise you to follow the described procedures, by doing so, you will most likely limit the functionality of not only our website but also most other websites, as the majority of modern websites use cookies.